Effect of different dietary ratios of corn silage to barley silage on fiber digestibility, feeding behavior, and milk yield performance of dairy cows

Document Type : Original Research Article (Regular Paper)


Department of Animal Science, College of Agriculture, Isfahan University of Technology, 84156–83111, Isfahan, Iran.


This study assessed the substitution effects of barley silage (BS) for corn silage (CS) on nutrient utilization, feeding behavior, and performance of dairy cows. Eight Holstein lactating cows were used in a replicated 4 × 4 Latin square design, and the cows were offered diets containing different ratios of CS to BS (22% of DM) as 1) 3:0 (CS3BS0); 2) 2:1 (CS2BS1); 3) 1:2 (CS1BS2); and 4) 0:3 (CS0BS3). The diets were iso-energetic and iso-nitrogenous, but the dietary concentration of indigestible neutral detergent fiber (iNDF) and proportion of long particles (>19 mm) were increased with increasing BS proportion in the diets‎. The degradability characteristics of the silages were evaluated by in situ technique. Both silages were similar in predicted total tract NDF digestibility (TTNDFD = 35 %), 30-h undegradable NDF (uNDF30h = 32 %), NDF digestion rate (kd = 1.8 %/h), but CS was lower in iNDF and higher non fibrous carbohydrates (NFC). Intake of DM was unchanged, but NDF intake was linearly increased with increasing BS levels. Total tract NDF digestibility did not differ among treatments, but DM digestibility linearly decreased with increasing BS proportion. Feeding different ratios of CS: BS did not affect milk yield or milk fat and protein concentration. Furthermore, ruminating time was unaffected by dietary treatments but increasing BS level decreased quadratically the eating and total chewing times. The experimental treatments did not affect plasma β-hydroxybutyric acid and glucose concentrations, but BS increased linearly ruminal ammonia and blood urea nitrogen concentration. The results indicated that BS had a higher iNDF content and a negative impact on DM digestibility and N utilization. However, partial or total substitution of CS with BS led to similar DM intake and milk yield, possibly as a result of similar fiber digestion rate and uNDF30h.


Main Subjects

  • AOAC, 2002. Official Methods of Analysis. 17th ed. Association of Official Analytical Chemists, Arlington, VA, USA.
  • Beauchemin, K.A., Yang, W.Z., 2005. Effects of physically effective fiber on intake, chewing activity, and ruminal acidosis for dairy cows fed diets based on corn silage. Journal of Dairy Science 88, 2117-2129.
  • Beauchemin, K.A., 2018. Invited review: Current perspectives on eating and rumination activity in dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 101, 4762-4784.
  • Benchaar, C., Hassanat, F., Gervais, R., Chouinard, P., Petit, H., Massé, D., 2014. Methane production, digestion, ruminal fermentation, nitrogen balance, and milk production of cows fed corn silage-or barley silage-based diets. Journal of Dairy Science 97, 961-974.
  • Broderick, G.A., Kang, J.H., 1980. Automated Simultaneous determination of ammonia and total amino acids in ruminal fluid and in vitro media. Journal of Dairy Science 63, 64-75.
  • Dado, R.G., Allen M.S., 1996. Enhanced intake and production of cows offered ensiled alfalfa with higher neutral detergent fiber digestibility. Journal of Dairy Science 79, 418-428.
  • Daynard, T.B., 1978. Practices affecting quality and preservation of whole-plant corn silage. Canadian Journal of Plant Science 58, 651-659.
  • Grant, R.J., & Cotanch, K.W., 2012. Higher forage diets: dynamics of passage, digestion, and cow productive responses. In: Proceedings Cornell Nutrition Conference for Feed Manufacturers. October 16-18, Syracuse, NY, USA. pp. 45-57.
  • Hosseini, M., Danesh Mesgaran, M., Vakili, A.R., Naserian, A.A., Khafipour, E., 2019. Altering undigested neutral detergent fiber through additives applied in corn, whole barley crop, and alfalfa silages, and its effect on performance of lactating Holstein dairy cows. Asian-Australasian Journal of Animal Science 32, 375-386.
  • Hristov, A., Ropp, J., Grandeen, K., Abedi, S., Etter, R., Melgar, A., Foley, A., 2005. Effect of carbohydrate source on ammonia utilization in lactating dairy cows. Journal of Animal Science 83, 408-421.
  • Huhtanen, P., Asikainen, U., Arkkila, M., Jaakkola, S. 2007., Cell wall digestion and passage kinetics estimated by marker and in situ methods or by rumen evacuations in cattle fed hay 2 or 18 times daily. Animal Feed Science and Technology 133, 206-227.
  • Kahyani, A., Ghorbani, G.R., Alikhani, M., Ghasemi, E., Sadeghi-Sefidmazgi, A., Nasrollahi, S. M., 2019. Adjusting for 30-hour undigested neutral detergent fiber in substitution of wheat straw and beet pulp for alfalfa hay and corn silage in the diet of high-producing cows. Journal of Dairy Science 102, 7026-7037.
  • Lopes, F., Cook, D., Combs, D., 2015. Validation of an in vitro model for predicting rumen and total-tract fiber digestibility in dairy cows fed corn silages with different in vitro neutral detergent fiber digestibilities at 2 levels of dry matter intake. Journal of Dairy Science 98, 574-585.
  • Lund, P., Weisbjerg, M.R., Hvelplund T., 2007. Digestible NDF is selectively retained in the rumen of dairy cows compared to indigestible NDF. Animal Feed Science and Technology 134, 1-17.
  • Mertens, D.R., 2016. Using uNDF to predict dairy cow performance and design rations. Pages 12–19 in Proc. Four-State Dairy Nutrition and Management Conference, Dubuque, IA. Iowa State University.
  • Migliorati, L., Boselli, L., Pirlo, G., Moschini, M., Masoero, F., 2017. Corn silage replacement with barley silage in dairy cows' diet does not change milk quality, cheese quality and yield. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 97, 3396-3401.
  • Molden, D., 2013. Water for food water for life: A Comprehensive Assessment of Water Management in Agriculture, International Water Management Institute, Colombo, Sri Lanka, Earthscan, London.
  • Nair, J., Christensen, D., Yu, P., Beattie, A.D., McAllister, T., Damiran, D., Fuhr, L., & McKinnon, J. J., 2016. A nutritional evaluation of common barley varieties grown for silage by beef and dairy producers in western Canada. Canadian Journal of Animal Science 96, 598-608.
  • Nazli, M.H., Halim, R.A., Abdullah, A.M., Hussin, G. Samsudin, A.A., 2019. Potential of four corn varieties at different harvest stages for silage production in Malaysia. Asian-Australasian Journal of Animal Sciences 32, 224-232.
  • NRC, 2001. Nutrient Requirements of Dairy Cattle. 7th revised ed. National Research Council, National Academy Press. Washington, DC, USA.
  • Oba, M., Allen, M.S., 1999a. Evaluation of the importance of NDF digestibility: Effects on dry matter intake and milk yield of dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 82, 589–596.
  • Oba, M., Allen, M.S., 1999b. Effects of brown midrib 3 mutation in corn silage on dry matter intake and productivity of high yielding dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 82, 135-142.
  • Refat, B., Christensen, D.A., Mckinnon, J.J., Prates, L.L., Nair, J., Beattie, A.D., Yang, W., McAllister, T.A., Yu, P., 2017a. Evaluation of barley silage with varying ruminal in vitro fiber digestibility on lactation performance and chewing activity of lactating dairy cows in comparison with corn silage. Canadian Journal of Animal Science 98, 177-186.
  • Refat, B., Yang, W., Christensen, D.A., Mckinnon, J.J., Beattie, A.D., Mcallister, T.A., Yu P., 2017b. Comparison of barley silages with varying digestible fiber content to corn silage on rumen fermentation characteristics and microbial protein synthesis using rumen simulation technique. Canadian Journal of Animal Science 97, 622-632.
  • Tudisco, R., Calabrò, S., Grossi, M., Piccolo, G., Guglielmelli, A., Cutrignelli, M.I., Caiazzo, C., Infascelli, F., 2010. Influence of replacing corn silage with barley silage in the diets of buffalo cows on milk yield and quality. Veterinary Research Communications 34, 193-196.
  • Van Keulen, V., Young, B.H., 1977. Evaluation of acid-insoluble ash as natural marker in ruminant digestibility studies. Journal of Animal Science 26, 119-135.
  • Van Soest, P.J., Robertson, J.B., Lewis, B.A., 1991. Methods for dietary fiber, neutral detergent fiber, and nonstarch polysaccharides in relation to animal nutrition. Journal of Dairy Science 74, 3583–3597.
  • Wallsten, J., Martinsson, K., 2009. Effects of maturity stage and feeding strategy of whole crop barley silage on intake, digestibility and milk production in dairy cows. Livestock Science 121, 155–161.
  • West, J.W., Hill, G.M., Gates, R.N., Mullinix, B.G., 1997. Effects of dietary forage source and amount of forage addition on intake, milk yield, and digestion for lactating dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 80, 1656-1665.
  • Zebeli, Q., Aschenbach, J.R., Tafaj, M., Boguhn, J., Ametaj, B.N., Drochner, W., 2012. Role of physically effective fiber and estimation of dietary fiber adequacy in high-producing dairy cattle. Journal of Dairy Science 95, 1041-1056.